Welcome to Neverland

This post may contain affiliate links.  You can Check my disclosure for more info!

And now for the group shot:

Ok, now for a run-dow of how everything was made:

Peter Pan: 
  • Hat from a friend
  • shirt is a small adult shirt, I just jagged-ly cut the arms and the bottom seam (and then put fray check on it so it won’t fray like crazy) then, I cut the collar (I thought I’d be able to turn the cut into a color, but that didn’t work so I had to add felt “lapels”, I put some eyelets in (hello scrapbooking) and laced some faux leather strips through it.
  • Pants were larger girl pants, but we liked the color and the general look, I hemmed them and also took them in on the bottoms (they were more of a flare leg) — also, I got the faux leather from the belt on this pants, so that saved me from having to buy something to work there.
  • Belt was an adult belt (albeit a small one) that I added a few extra holes in so it’d fit Conner.
  • Sword from Rite-Aid

Total cost probably about 15 dollars

  • Hat is an old hat we found at a garage sale, I covered it in felt, used styrafoam balls and googly eyes.  The little “spikes” are 1/2 circles that I turned into cones and put a cotton ball inside and glued on.  If you see this hat up close it has a LOT of hot glue on it.  I’m talking 5 or 6 sticks. :)
  • Pants and shirt were found at Savers (as was pretty much all the basic supplies), soccer socks are old ones from Conner.
  • His “sandwich” top is just “tiles” of scales and strips of scales.  I made the basic shape out of felt and then just glued everything else on.
  • I made the basic tail shape out of green fleece and then made spikes out of yellow fleece (stuffed with old grocery bags) and sewed those together.  Then, before stuffing the tail we added an old coat hanger and stuffed it pretty full.  Then, I sewed it onto a waist band of covered elastic (covered with green fleece).

Total cost: about 15 dollars

  • Took a nightgown I found at Savers and dyed it and then added a blue ribbon from Michael’s. 

Total cost:  about 12 dollars

  • Hat is made from an old infant hat (which is slowly being out grown), covered in triangles of yellow fleece.  Took a styrafoam ball, covered it with fleece, hot glued it on and added a bow.  This was by far the largest part, but it really makes the costume, I think.
  • Onsie found at Savers
  • Tights we already had
  • Shoes were made from green felt from this pattern.  Actually fairly easy, I think they only took 1/2 an hour but they just BARELY fit her.  Added yellow bows to cover the elastic.  These shoes are great though, I might enlarge the pattern and make her a couple other pair.
  • Wings from Joann’s (with a coupon)
  • Tutu had a couple of steps.  Cut elastic to fit, added some hook and loop closures at the ends, sewed on some green “leaves” then I tied some strips of lighter and darker green tule and finally some green ribbon I had lying around.  Pretty dang cute.

total cost: about 14 dollars

Captain Hook

  • Hat borrowed from a friend (the hat makes it, I am so glad they let us borrow it)

  • Wig from Rite Aid (nasty wig too, btw)
  • Coat is a bathrobe from Savers, I added some gold braiding to it and sewed down the “lapel” so that it’d look more “coat-like”, also sewed lace onto the bottoms of the sleeves
  • Shirt is a turtle-neck from Savers, I added a lace “triagle” to it
  • Pants are women’s capris (from savers — Drew and I were talking about how most of his costume came from the women’s section)
  • Socks are mine

 Total Cost: about 35 dollars

Favorite part: I like that our family stands out, I like that our kids will have the memory that we did this with/for them.
Least Favorite part: The sewing.  I’m always swearing at the machine, at the fabric, at myself for deciding to do it.  But it’s worth it.  They’ve all had a lot of fun. 

Oh, and big props to Andrea, Drew’s cousin for taking the photos and watching my munchkins while I helped out at school.  I am almost ready to claim her as a relative, and that’s saying a lot. :)

So, whatcha think?

Pulling Curls blog by Hilary EricksonCheck out Hilary's Most Popular Posts ~ Learn more About Hilary

Like me on Facebook!
Menu Plan Monday
Favorites Friday


  1. says

    You rock. I swear, I’m going to start next year’s costumes next week, just so I can be as cool as you. We aren’t very cool this year. :)

    You guys look amazing. Love the pictures.

  2. says

    Wow. Everything looks great. I’m so envious of people that can sew. It’s my quest to learn this next year. I’m learning to can on Monday from my dear grandma. I went to local farms to get a box of apples to have her show me how to can applesauce for my bday.

  3. says

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>